Some psychologists and psychiatrists are upset about a big contradiction in society: how can we try to stop people from committing suicide while also saying that, in some cases, it’s okay to help someone die? Over 600 mental health professionals signed a statement against a proposed law that would allow assisted dying, arguing that this creates a confusing and harmful message. They believe it is not right to say that some lives are not worth living.
They ask, “How can we help our patients who are struggling with thoughts of death if we also suggest that for some, dying is a solution?” Allowing euthanasia and assisted suicide sends a very dangerous message: that some lives don’t deserve to be lived. This could push vulnerable people who are already struggling closer to the edge.
These mental health professionals work hard to give hope to those who feel hopeless. They know that emotional suffering can happen to anyone, especially to people who are elderly, isolated, or sick. They warn that by allowing doctors to help someone die, society is subtly telling all vulnerable people that dying might be an option worth considering.
They argue that supporting the idea of assisted dying creates a dangerous distinction between types of suffering—some that deserve support and others that justify ending a life. This could have serious consequences for suicide prevention. If society implies that death is a valid option, how can we convince desperate people to keep fighting for their lives?
The professionals emphasize that this law doesn’t give rights to vulnerable people; instead, it adds pressure on them. It makes them feel like a burden and takes away the chance for meaningful support and companionship, which can lead to new possibilities.
Countries that have legalized assisted dying, such as the Netherlands and Oregon, have seen increases in suicide rates. In the Netherlands, non-assisted suicides rose by 28% between 2010 and 2021, while other European countries without legalized euthanasia saw their suicide rates go down. This suggests that legalizing assisted suicide can normalize the idea of suicide.
These psychologists and psychiatrists refuse to stand by and watch as society gives up on helping those in need. They believe that allowing death as a response to emotional suffering betrays their mission to care for patients. They see it as encouraging suicide and undermining their efforts and values. Instead of showing compassion, they believe this approach is a surrender.
They firmly state that they will always support those who are suffering and will not allow society to become a tool for those in despair. They believe that the true measure of progress in society is how well it protects and supports its most vulnerable members, not how easily it allows for their disappearance. They want to stay true to values like solidarity, humanity, and care.
This article has been translated and simplified by artificial intelligence from a French article “« Droit à l’aide à mourir » : « c’est une capitulation, pas une compassion »”
It may therefore contain errors. The French version is the reference version..